About Schmidt

I was so offended by the cynicism and class condescension of Citizen Ruth, Alexander Payne’s first feature, that I’ve remained suspicious of his work even as he’s emerged as a more skillful director in Election and this still more ambitious and accomplished film. It’s a very free adaptation of a Louis Begley novel, transposed from Manhattan to Payne’s native Nebraska, in which Jack Nicholson has been asked to put on some weight and finally act his age. The problem is he’s still Jack Nicholson, exuding his know-it-all charisma even when playing a clueless asshole and not nearly as inventive as he was in a much less showy part in The Pledge. The contrivance here by which he bares his soulby mouthing letters to an African boy he’s helping to support from afaris bogus and forced, and even the more observant moments in this odyssey of a bored and boring widower can’t entirely escape the jeering tone that remains Payne’s stock-in-trade. Much more deserving of plaudits is the secondary castHope Davis as Schmidt’s resentful daughter, Dermot Mulroney as the water-bed salesman she’s engaged to, and, above all, Kathy Bates in a hilarious turn as the latter’s New Age mother. 124 min. (JR)

This entry was posted in Featured Texts. Bookmark the permalink.